- Thank you received: 0
Why doesn't the moon leave earth's orbit?
21 years 11 months ago #3439
by Jim
Replied by Jim on topic Reply from
My mission is a bit more involved than doing math. The model does a very good job at predicting everything anyone wants to know about tides. So, no I am not trying to determine how much of the tide is gravity induced.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Quantum_Gravity
- Offline
- Premium Member
Less
More
- Thank you received: 0
21 years 11 months ago #3456
by Quantum_Gravity
Replied by Quantum_Gravity on topic Reply from Randall damron
Thank you for clarifying that, and to the 3rd power is a good model. what wsas your source or your own idea?
The intuitive mind
The intuitive mind
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
21 years 11 months ago #3896
by Jim
Replied by Jim on topic Reply from
The idea that the 3rd power law is bogus is mine. I spent a lot of time and energy on the research of the tide model which was designed by Newton and while it is excellent as a practical matter this model is based on observations Newton made that tides are higher when the Earth,moon and sun are in a line than when the three bodies are not aligned. So he just found a relationship that worked out to a third power of distance. But, as I have said before if the 3rd power of distance law is true then the tides should be 40% higher when the moon is nearest the Earth and this is not observed. It has been argued that the tide is 40% higher at sometime during the cycle. This is true, but, that is the spring/neap tidal cycle which has nothing whatsoever to do with the distance between Earth and moon.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- MarkVitrone
- Offline
- Platinum Member
Less
More
- Thank you received: 0
21 years 11 months ago #3467
by MarkVitrone
Replied by MarkVitrone on topic Reply from Mark Vitrone
I am curious about two moon related phenomena
1. How deeply does a tidal effect penetrate the planet's surface? Are there any models that relate chemistry, density, and phase to tidal distortion.
2. Can or do any of the solar system's moons have any satelites of their own?
Thanks MV
1. How deeply does a tidal effect penetrate the planet's surface? Are there any models that relate chemistry, density, and phase to tidal distortion.
2. Can or do any of the solar system's moons have any satelites of their own?
Thanks MV
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
21 years 11 months ago #3769
by Atko
Replied by Atko on topic Reply from Paul Atkinson
Jim
Not had time to look in recently, so apologies for tardy response time on this. More apologies for mentioning Spring and Neap tides above - these have nothing to do with the meat of the discussion and aren't what the numbers I quoted are calculating. It's just a formula for tidal force for any extra-terrestrial mass effecting the oceans. I have it on good authority that the tidal effect of the Moon at closest range does raise the tides 48%, not into simple linear 48% high seas raging tsunamis all over the planet, but 48% higher than the force when the Moon is at furthest distance. As I said before, what are <b>you</b> expecting the difference in tidal effects to be between nearest and farthest approach - this isn't clear in any of your posts?
Not had time to look in recently, so apologies for tardy response time on this. More apologies for mentioning Spring and Neap tides above - these have nothing to do with the meat of the discussion and aren't what the numbers I quoted are calculating. It's just a formula for tidal force for any extra-terrestrial mass effecting the oceans. I have it on good authority that the tidal effect of the Moon at closest range does raise the tides 48%, not into simple linear 48% high seas raging tsunamis all over the planet, but 48% higher than the force when the Moon is at furthest distance. As I said before, what are <b>you</b> expecting the difference in tidal effects to be between nearest and farthest approach - this isn't clear in any of your posts?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
21 years 11 months ago #3773
by Jim
Replied by Jim on topic Reply from
As to the question of how far into Earth the tidal effect penetrates-I wonder about this too. I suspect the force is totally dissipated by the ocean, but, all models(and experts) say the force effects the solid crust and the mantle/core. As to the question of how much the tides are raised by the moon being at perigee and apogee there is no measured difference in the tides due to this cycle in fact or in models.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.344 seconds